Rinsed in the shower this morning, re-inserted. And I guess maybe I hit it at a different angle or something because it went a good bit farther in today than it did yesterday.
Then I went to the bathroom a little bit ago and I checked it when I was done... and that thing is WAY up in there. Now I'm concerned. Just exactly how far in is that thing supposed to go? It's not going to get sucked all the way inside, is it?